On inconsistent jurisprudence of application of the rule of law obliging respondents to publish through mass media or a different way of decision of the courts in claims in protection of legitimate interests of an uncertain circle of consumers in case of their satisfaction

K A Korchagina; V A Turovskaya

ON INCONSISTENT JURISPRUDENCE OF APPLICATION OF THE RULE OF LAW OBLIGING RESPONDENTS TO PUBLISH THROUGH MASS MEDIA OR A DIFFERENT WAY OF DECISION OF THE COURTS IN CLAIMS IN PROTECTION OF LEGITIMATE INTERESTS OF AN UNCERTAIN CIRCLE OF CONSUMERS IN CASE OF THEIR SATISFACTION On inconsistent jurisprudence of application of the rule of law obliging respondents to publish through mass media or a different way of decision of the courts in claims in protection of legitimate interests of an uncertain circle of consumers in case of their satisfaction

АА Аа

Published in Bulletin of the Kazan Law Institute of MIA Russia · Pages 37–41 · Rubric: STATE, CIVIL, ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

Received: 12.06.2017 Accepted: 20.06.2017 Published: 25.06.2017 Language of publication: RUS

Authors

K A Korchagina

V A Turovskaya

K A Korchagina

Rostovskiy yuridicheskiy institut MVD Rossii

V A Turovskaya

Departament lesnogo hozyaystva po Dal'nevostochnomu federal'nomu okrugu

ABSTRACT

The problem of the abstract formulation of provision of Article 46 of the law «On Protection of Consumers’ Rights» about assignment of the duty on the respondent in bringing a judgment to consumers arising at satisfaction of the claim of authorized supervisory authority for the termination of illegal actions of economic entities concerning an uncertain circle of consumers is described. The conclusion that the specified norm is not only an opening in the legislation for unfair economic entities is drawn, but is the promotion of formation of inconsistent, negative and inefficient jurisprudence locates.

KEYWORDS

uncertain circle of consumers, judgment, supervisory authority, federal state supervision in the field of consumer protection, mass media, economic entities

1. O zaschite prav potrebiteley: zakon RF ot 7 fevralya 1992 goda № 2300-1 // Vedomosti SND i VS RF 1992. № 15. St. 766; Rossiyskaya gazeta. 1996. 16 yanvarya.

2. Polozhenie o Federal'noy sluzhbe po nadzoru v sfere zaschity prav potrebiteley i blagopoluchiya cheloveka, utverzhdennoe postanovleniem Pravitel'stva RF ot 30 iyunya 2004 g. № 322 // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 2004. 8 iyulya.

3. Zaschita prav potrebiteley v Rossiyskoy Federacii v 2015 godu: Gosudarstvennyy doklad. M. : Federal'naya sluzhba po nadzoru v sfere zaschity prav potrebiteley i blagopoluchiya cheloveka, 2016. 300 s. [Elektronnyy resurs]. URL : http://rospotrebnadzor.ru/documents/details.php?ELEMENT_ID=6697&sphrase_id=731950, svobodnyy (data obrascheniya : 03.03.2016).

4. Reshenie Belozerskogo rayonnogo suda Kurganskoy oblasti № 2-170/2012 O priznanii deystviy otvetchika protivopravnymi v otnoshenii neopredelennogo kruga potrebiteley i o vozlozhenii obyazannosti dovesti reshenie suda do svedeniya potrebiteley. [Elektronnyy resurs] URL : http://www.gcourts.ru/case/8677122, svobodnyy. Data obrascheniya : 03.03.2016; Reshenie Belozerskogo rayonnogo suda Kurganskoy oblasti № 2-171/2012 O priznanii deystviy otvetchika protivopravnymi v otnoshenii neopredelennogo kruga potrebiteley i o vozlozhenii obyazannosti dovesti reshenie suda do svedeniya potrebiteley. [Elektronnyy resurs] URL : http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/nTpaMoHNBiLl/, svobodnyy (data obrascheniya: 01.05.2016); Reshenie Belozerskogo rayonnogo suda Kurganskoy oblasti № 2-445/2011 O priznanii deystviy otvetchika protivopravnymi v otnoshenii neopredelennogo kruga potrebiteley i o vozlozhenii obyazannosti dovesti reshenie suda do svedeniya potrebiteley. [Elektronnyy resurs] URL : http://docs.pravo.ru/document/view/21217611/20354830/, svobodnyy (data obrascheniya: 03.06.2016); Reshenie Taganrogskogo gorodskogo suda Rostovskoy oblasti po delu № 2-7255/10 ot 15.12 2010 g. [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

5. Postanovlenie Prezidiuma Verhovnogo Suda Respubliki Komi ot 05 noyabrya 2014 g. po delu № 4G-963/2014 [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

6. Reshenie Dzerzhinskogo gorodskogo suda Nizhegorodskoy oblasti ot 03 avgusta 2012 g. po isku Nizhegorodskoy oblastnoy obschestvennoy organizacii «Komitet po zaschite prav potrebiteley» v interesah neopredelennogo kruga lic k Bazhutovoy E.M. o vozlozhenii obyazannosti ustranit' dopuschennye narusheniya (Izvlechenie). [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy; Reshenie Dzerzhinskogo gorodskogo suda Nizhegorodskoy oblasti ot 02 avgusta 2012 g. po isku Nizhegorodskoy oblastnoy obschestvennoy organizacii «Komitet po zaschite prav potrebiteley» v interesah neopredelennogo kruga lic k Astaf'evoy Yu.A. o vozlozhenii obyazannosti ustranit' dopuschennye narusheniya (Izvlechenie) [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

7. Postanovlenie Plenuma Verhovnogo Suda RF ot 28 iyunya 2012 g. № 17 «O rassmotrenii sudami grazhdanskih del po sporam o zaschite prav potrebiteley» [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravo-vaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

8. Reshenie Millerovskogo rayonnogo suda Rostovskoy oblasti ot 25 sentyabrya 2012 g. po iskovomu zayavleniyu Upravleniya Rospotrebnadzora po Rostovskoy oblasti k IP Sidorovoy A.K. o priznanii protivopravnymi deystviy v otnoshenii neopredelennogo kruga potrebiteley (Izvlechenie). [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy; Reshenie Millerovskogo rayonnogo suda Rostovskoy oblasti ot 10 sentyabrya 2012 g. po iskovomu zayavleniyu Upravleniya Rospotrebnadzora po Rostovskoy oblasti k Bilevich Elene Aleksandrovne o priznanii nezakonnymi deystviy v otnoshenii neopredelennogo kruga potrebiteley (Izvlechenie) [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy; Reshenie Millerovskogo rayonnogo suda Rostovskoy oblasti ot 19 sentyabrya 2012 g. po iskovomu zayavleniyu Upravleniya Rospotrebnadzora po Rostovskoy oblasti k OOO «Kopeyka» o priznanii protivopravnymi deystviy v otnoshenii neopredelennogo kruga potrebiteley (Izvlechenie) [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

9. Spravka po rezul'tatam obobscheniya sudebnoy praktiki rassmotreniya sudami Permskogo kraya del po sporam o zaschite prav potrebiteley za 2013 - 2014 gody (utv. na zasedanii Prezidiuma Permskogo kraevogo suda ot 27 marta 2015 g.) [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

10. Reshenie Boksitogorskogo gorodskogo suda Leningradskoy oblasti ot 19 yanvarya 2012 g. po delu № 2-40/12. [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

11. Reshenie Lebedyanskogo rayonnogo suda Lipeckoy oblasti ot 29 avgusta 2012 g. po delu № 2-612/2012. [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

12. Zakon RF ot 27.12.1991 N 2124-1 «O sredstvah massovoy informacii» // Rossiyskaya gazeta. 992. 8 fevralya.

13. Spravka po rezul'tatam obobscheniya sudebnoy praktiki rassmotreniya sudami Permskogo kraya del po sporam o zaschite prav potrebiteley za 2013 - 2014 gody (utv. na zasedanii Prezidiuma Permskogo kraevogo suda ot 27 marta 2015 g.) [Elektronnyy resurs] : Spravochnaya pravovaya sistema «Garant». Rezhim dostupa: lokal'nyy.

14. Turovskaya V.A., Korchagina K.A. Ispolnenie poslaniy Prezidenta RF k Parlamentu kak sposob zarozhdeniya novyh garantiy zaschity prav hozyaystvuyuschih sub'ektov pri osuschestvlenii gosudarstvennogo kontrolya i nadzora // Rossiyskaya yusticiya. 2016. № 1. S. 53-56.

15. Turovskaya V.A. Uvedomitel'nyy poryadok planovyh proverok yuridicheskih lic i individual'nyh predprinimateley : lazeyki v zakonodatel'stve // Gosudarstvennaya vlast' i mestnoe samoupravlenie. 2013. № 8. S. 47- 49.

This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International

JATS XML

editorial office

Redakciya "Vestnik KYuI MVD Rossii"

This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Creative Commons

GOST

, On inconsistent jurisprudence of application of the rule of law obliging respondents to publish through mass media or a different way of decision of the courts in claims in protection of legitimate interests of an uncertain circle of consumers in case of their satisfaction // . 2017. pp. 37-41. (Date of access 19.08.2026).

MLA

K A Korchagina, . "On inconsistent jurisprudence of application of the rule of law obliging respondents to publish through mass media or a different way of decision of the courts in claims in protection of legitimate interests of an uncertain circle of consumers in case of their satisfaction." (2017): 37-41.

APA

, (2017). On inconsistent jurisprudence of application of the rule of law obliging respondents to publish through mass media or a different way of decision of the courts in claims in protection of legitimate interests of an uncertain circle of consumers in case of their satisfaction. , 37-41.

Chicago

WIKI

{{cite journal | author = , | title = On inconsistent jurisprudence of application of the rule of law obliging respondents to publish through mass media or a different way of decision of the courts in claims in protection of legitimate interests of an uncertain circle of consumers in case of their satisfaction | journal = | year = 2017 | pages = 37-41 }}

Copy

Export: BibTeX EndNote RefMan RusMARC

Confirmation